Gum Hotel Garrard

The Observer 13/9/1862 3g.

Supreme Court—Civil Side. PEARSE V. VORWERK

This was an action for £189 8s. 9d., for work done and materials provided. During the hearing of the preceding cause Mr Andrews, whom appeared for the defendant, applied on affidavit that the case might be postponed on account of the absence of his client, who before the declaration was filed had gone a long distance into the country. His Honour declined to grant the application. Mr Fenn, who attended for the plaintiff, opened the case to the Jury, and called Richard Pearse, car¬penter and builder—Remembered entering into a contract with the defendant for building the District Hotel at Gumeracha. Was applied to by the defendant to prepare plans and specifica¬tions. There was no price agreed upon, but he charged 2 1/2 percent for preparing them. The usual charge was 5 percent. Superintended the builders’ work. His estimate of the whole work was £1,300. Entered into a contract to do the carpentering work for £500. Supplied scaffolding for the use of the masons and bricklayers, and charged £5. Subsequently received orders to fit up bar, &c., independent of the original contract. Served the defendant with a copy of his bill for those extras in May last. All the work charged for in the bill of particulars was performed by him, and the prices set down for the various items were moderate and fair. Had received on ac¬count of the original contract £499 9s. 3d. Had not received payment for any part of the extra work. Had applied for payment on two or three occasions. Had had the extra work valued by Mr Hall. He valued it in his presence.

By Mr Andrews—There was no contract in writing between them. Was in the habit of drawing plans when requested. Mr Vorwerk never stated he would pay for the plan in addition to the other work. The defendant did not promise to pay him for drawing the plan and supervising the masonry work. Brought Mr Hall to value the work for his own satisfaction. It was the custom to procure a person to value the work. Had heard that Mr Watts went over the work on the part of the defendant. Heard that he made the amount £121. Mr Hall valued the work before Mr Watts. His own valuation of the work was £151, exclusive of the charge for drawing up the specifica¬tions and the loan of the scaffolding. James Hall, carpenter and builder, of Mount Pleasant. Had been requested by the plaintiff to value some work for him at the District Hotel, Gumeracha. The work was pointed out to him by the plaintiff, and the articles he went over he valued at £140 9s. Had been in the trade from his youth.

By Mr Andrews—Had not the several charges made by the last witness in his hand while valuing the work. Did not meet Mr Watts at the hotel. Never heard that he had valued the work. Did not know there was a difference of opinion as to the value of the work until after he had been sub¬poenaed. Could not swear that it was a custom to call in another person to value when there was no written agreement as to the amount of money to be paid for work done.

By Mr Fenn—Could not say whether it was the practice of the trade to call in a valuator when there was a likelihood of their being compelled to institute a suit for the payment of their ac-count. Never had to bring an action to recover payment for work he had performed. Mr Fenn, addressing the Jury, said it appeared there was only one difficulty in the way of the plaintiff, and that was that he had been too cautious, and had handed in another man’s calculation of the value of the work instead of his own. He (Mr Fenn) trusted they would not be prejudiced against him by the superabundance of evidence in his favour, and that they would come to the conclusion that he was entitled to the full amount of the claim, £189 8s. 9d. He would surely be deserving of some compensation for preparing the plans and specifications and generally supervising the work, and £32 10s., one half the usual charge, could not surely be objected to as unreasonable.

Mr Andrews said it might appear strange that he had not called evidence in defence; but the Jury would remember that an affidavit had been read from him in the course of the morning applying for an adjournment of the case on the ground of the unavoidable absence of the defendant, so that this omission was sufficiently explained. It was quite evident that work had been done and mate¬rials furnished by the plaintiff, and he was entitled to a verdict. The amount of that verdict was the chief question for their consideration. Being a German, the defendant was not likely to be able to criticise the bill so elaborately drawn out in English; but it must have been evident to the plaintiff, from his having employed a valuator, that he had had no intention to pay the whole sum charged in the bill. His learned friend was therefore not quite correct in saying that he had prom-ised to discharge the whole sum. He might say also that 2 1/2 percent was the full charge of an architect in superintending work, so that the sum of £38 could not be regarded as a moderate charge; but he would submit that, as there had been no agreement with regard to that £38 for specifications, the plaintiff could not properly claim compensation for having prepared them. As to the rest, the absence of the defendant placed him in the position of being unable to rebut the statements alleged on behalf of the plaintiff.

His Honour summed up, and the Jury having retired for a few minutes, returned a verdict for the full amount, £189 8s. 9d.